« One World Youth Project | Main | Investing Limited Resources - Questions »

December 20, 2007

Comments

Brad Jolly

John, I commend you for recognizing the importance of educational choice in attracting high-quality jobs.

You are also right that this is yet another area where St. Vrain falls short of even having a "basic package."

According to page 3 of the district's own 2006-07 Annual Report, the district has grown by 2,848 students in the last four years, but 83% of that growth (2,357 students) is in the "free and reduced lunch" demographic. This suggests that the district is not extraordinarily attractive to the high- or medium-income demographic that generally improves a district's academic results.

I am deeply concerned that this is becoming a vicious cycle. The district's failurist funding model and low expectations cause parents who can afford better alternatives to flee, thus raising the percentage of students from low-achieving socioeconomic groups. The need to accommodate these students leads to further funding distortions and even lower standards, and the cycle continues.

Your solution is to create large amounts of choice within the school district, but that is clearly years away from becoming reality. If we fail to act now, the cycle will continue, and it may be too late by the time choices become available.

The best solution for all of the citizens in the area is a dual-pronged approach of a) reforming the district toward excellence to attract the parents who are presently repelled by the district's low standards, and b) promoting and encouraging educational alternatives (charter schools, homeschools, private schools and parochial schools) to at least keep the parents that the district has repelled from leaving the area altogether.

The comments to this entry are closed.